Is Your Jesus a Registered Voter?
Caesar Can Have the Coin, But He Can’t Have You: Allegiance and Identity in Mark 12:13–17
The election is over. Some of us are relieved, some are anxious, and many of us are tired.
In this episode we go back to an old trap: in Mark 12, the Pharisees and Herodians try to make Jesus pick a side on paying taxes to Rome. Jesus won’t accept the terms of their question, and he doesn’t dodge it either. He asks for a coin, asks whose image is on it, and redraws the whole map of allegiance.
We look at how political identity has become tangled up with Christian identity, on the right and on the left. We ask whether Jesus is shaping our politics or whether our politics are reshaping Jesus. We also look at what Scripture really says about governing power, which is the good servant of Romans 13 and the beast demanding worship in Revelation 13, and at the line between them.
In this episode:
• Why “being a good, moral Christian” can hide the real question: where is your treasure? (Matthew 6:21)
• The trap in Mark 12:13–17, and the odd political alliances that form against Jesus
• Whose image do you bear? The coin carries Caesar’s image, but you carry God’s (Genesis 1:27), and so does your political opponent.
• What Tiberius’s denarius actually said: “son of the divine Augustus,” high priest. The coin wasn’t just money. It made a theological claim.
• Government under God, never in God’s place: reading Romans 13 and Revelation 13 together
• Paul gives Caesar’s titles, Savior and Lord, to Jesus (Philippians 3:20)
• “My kingdom is not of this world” (John 18:36): a kingdom that doesn’t advance by force or by winning
• Civil freedom vs. gospel freedom: no election gave you your freedom in Christ, and no election can take it away (John 8:36; 2 Corinthians 3:17)
A heart check: What makes you anxious? What are you afraid of losing? Where do you go for hope?
Key texts: Mark 12:13–17 · Genesis 1:27 · Matthew 6:21 · Romans 13:1–7 · Revelation 13 · Philippians 3:20 · John 18:33–38; 19:11 · John 8:36 · 2 Corinthians 3:17 · 1 Peter 2:17 · Acts 5:29
For reflection:
1 When did your political convictions last change because of Jesus, rather than the other way around?
2 How did you feel on election night? What does that reaction say about where your hope is?
3 Who is a person “on the other side” who bears God’s image, and how might that change how you talk about them this week?
4 Where is the line between honoring the authorities and giving them what belongs only to God?
Takeaway: Pay the tax. Pray for leaders, including the ones you didn’t vote for. Seek the good of the city. Speak up when power oversteps. But keep your worship, your ultimate loyalty and your hope of salvation for the One whose image you bear.
