Under God, Never in God's Place
Romans 13, Revelation 13, and how American Christians can hold government in its place
Two weeks after the 2026 midterms, American Christians are processing the results in very different ways. Some conservative evangelical leaders have described themselves as disappointed, even devastated. Some progressive Christians are celebrating a "religious left" that helped flip Congress. The emotional temperature in both camps tells us something worth paying attention to.
This isn't a post about who should have won. It's about a question underneath every election: what is government for, and how much of our hearts should it get? Scripture answers with two pictures of governing power, and I'm convinced we need both.
Picture one: government as God's servant
In Romans 13, Paul says governing authorities are instituted by God. He calls the ruler "God's servant for your good."
Government has a real and good job: to restrain evil, to protect the vulnerable, and to keep enough order that people can live, work and raise families. Paul tells the church to pay taxes and to give honor where honor is due.
Remember who was on the throne when Paul wrote this. It was Nero. Paul wasn't endorsing the emperor. He was putting the emperor in his place, and that place is servant. Romans 13 is not a blank check for power. It is a job description, and the job is service under God.
Picture two: government as beast
In Revelation 13, John looks at the same empire and sees a beast. It rises from the sea, and the whole earth worships it. People cry out, "Who is like the beast? Who can fight against it?" That is a deliberate echo of Israel's old song at the sea: "Who is like you, O Lord?" (Exodus 15:11).
The beast decides who can buy and who can sell. It demands not only taxes but worship. It promises security and belonging in exchange for total loyalty.
What changed? The claim
What changed between Romans 13 and Revelation 13? Not the structure. It's still Rome. What changed is the claim. In Romans 13, governing power serves under God. In Revelation 13, it has taken God's place.
Any government becomes beastly when it asks for what belongs only to God: our ultimate loyalty, our worship, our hope of salvation. And here's the part we often miss. Government doesn't always have to demand that worship. Sometimes we offer it freely.
Scripture holds both truths, so we must too. If we read only Romans 13, we end up baptizing whatever power is in charge. If we read only Revelation 13, we end up treating all government as the enemy and stepping away from our neighbors. Neither is faithful.
Notice how neatly this maps onto American habits. Many of us are Romans 13 Christians when our side holds power and Revelation 13 Christians when it doesn't. The text we reach for tends to change with the election results. That alone should make us suspicious of ourselves.
How do we live with both?
Paul gives us a clue in his letter to Philippi. Philippi was a Roman colony, and its people were proud of their Roman citizenship. So Paul's words would have landed hard: "Our citizenship is in heaven, and from it we await a Savior, the Lord Jesus Christ" (Philippians 3:20). Savior and Lord were titles people used for Caesar. Paul takes Caesar's titles and gives them to Jesus. Rome is not your Savior. Rome is not your Lord. You carry a passport from somewhere else.
Then there's Jesus himself, standing before Pilate in John 18. Pilate, the man with all the power in the room, asks, "Are you a king?" Jesus answers, "My kingdom is not of this world. If it were, my servants would be fighting."
Jesus isn't saying his kingdom is unreal or only about the afterlife. He's saying it doesn't come from this world, and it doesn't advance the way this world's kingdoms do. It doesn't come by force, by winning, or by taking control. It comes by truth.
A chapter later, Jesus tells Pilate he would have no authority at all unless it had been given him from above (John 19:11). Pilate thinks he's judging Jesus. In fact, Pilate stands under God's authority too. So does every president, every Congress, every governor, and every court.
What this means for American politics right now
What this means for the American church
Stop making party loyalty a test of faithfulness. In many congregations, the quickest way to have your faith questioned is to vote differently from the people in the next pew. But no ballot is a confession of faith. The church confesses "Jesus is Lord," a claim no party platform can contain. When we treat political conclusions as tests of orthodoxy, we have quietly let Caesar write our membership requirements.
Let discipleship shape politics, not the reverse. The real question is which direction the influence runs. Are we reading the news through the Gospels, or the Gospels through the news? A simple check is to ask when Scripture last changed your mind on a political question. If the answer is never, the lens may be pointing the wrong way.
Distinguish civil freedom from gospel freedom. The freedom to speak, gather and worship is a real gift. We should protect it, be grateful for it, and seek it for our neighbors as well as ourselves. But it is not the freedom of the gospel. "If the Son sets you free, you will be free indeed" (John 8:36). Paul had that freedom in chains. Believers under hostile governments have it today. No election gave it to you, and no election can take it away.
Be the kind of community the world can't produce. A local church where people who voted differently still share the table, pray together and serve the same neighbors is itself a witness. It shows a kingdom that "doesn't come from this world" and doesn't advance by winning. In a polarized season, that may be the most countercultural thing a congregation can do.
Pray for leaders by name, especially the ones you didn't vote for. Paul urges prayers "for kings and all who are in high positions" (1 Timothy 2:1-2). With power now divided in Washington, every Christian has someone in office they would rather not pray for. That is exactly where the practice works on us.
Fear God. Honor the emperor.
Peter puts it in four short phrases: "Honor everyone. Love the brotherhood. Fear God. Honor the emperor" (1 Peter 2:17). Fear goes to God. Honor goes to the emperor. Never mix them up.
So pay the tax. Pray for those in authority. Seek the good of the city. Speak up when power oversteps. But keep your worship, your ultimate loyalty and your hope of salvation for the One whose image you bear. Government under God, never in God's place.
Questions for reflection
Two weeks after the 2026 midterms, American Christians are processing the results in very different ways. Some conservative evangelical leaders have described themselves as disappointed, even devastated. Some progressive Christians are celebrating a "religious left" that helped flip Congress. The emotional temperature in both camps tells us something worth paying attention to.
This isn't a post about who should have won. It's about a question underneath every election: what is government for, and how much of our hearts should it get? Scripture answers with two pictures of governing power, and I'm convinced we need both.
Picture one: government as God's servant
In Romans 13, Paul says governing authorities are instituted by God. He calls the ruler "God's servant for your good."
Government has a real and good job: to restrain evil, to protect the vulnerable, and to keep enough order that people can live, work and raise families. Paul tells the church to pay taxes and to give honor where honor is due.
Remember who was on the throne when Paul wrote this. It was Nero. Paul wasn't endorsing the emperor. He was putting the emperor in his place, and that place is servant. Romans 13 is not a blank check for power. It is a job description, and the job is service under God.
Picture two: government as beast
In Revelation 13, John looks at the same empire and sees a beast. It rises from the sea, and the whole earth worships it. People cry out, "Who is like the beast? Who can fight against it?" That is a deliberate echo of Israel's old song at the sea: "Who is like you, O Lord?" (Exodus 15:11).
The beast decides who can buy and who can sell. It demands not only taxes but worship. It promises security and belonging in exchange for total loyalty.
What changed? The claim
What changed between Romans 13 and Revelation 13? Not the structure. It's still Rome. What changed is the claim. In Romans 13, governing power serves under God. In Revelation 13, it has taken God's place.
Any government becomes beastly when it asks for what belongs only to God: our ultimate loyalty, our worship, our hope of salvation. And here's the part we often miss. Government doesn't always have to demand that worship. Sometimes we offer it freely.
Scripture holds both truths, so we must too. If we read only Romans 13, we end up baptizing whatever power is in charge. If we read only Revelation 13, we end up treating all government as the enemy and stepping away from our neighbors. Neither is faithful.
Notice how neatly this maps onto American habits. Many of us are Romans 13 Christians when our side holds power and Revelation 13 Christians when it doesn't. The text we reach for tends to change with the election results. That alone should make us suspicious of ourselves.
How do we live with both?
Paul gives us a clue in his letter to Philippi. Philippi was a Roman colony, and its people were proud of their Roman citizenship. So Paul's words would have landed hard: "Our citizenship is in heaven, and from it we await a Savior, the Lord Jesus Christ" (Philippians 3:20). Savior and Lord were titles people used for Caesar. Paul takes Caesar's titles and gives them to Jesus. Rome is not your Savior. Rome is not your Lord. You carry a passport from somewhere else.
Then there's Jesus himself, standing before Pilate in John 18. Pilate, the man with all the power in the room, asks, "Are you a king?" Jesus answers, "My kingdom is not of this world. If it were, my servants would be fighting."
Jesus isn't saying his kingdom is unreal or only about the afterlife. He's saying it doesn't come from this world, and it doesn't advance the way this world's kingdoms do. It doesn't come by force, by winning, or by taking control. It comes by truth.
A chapter later, Jesus tells Pilate he would have no authority at all unless it had been given him from above (John 19:11). Pilate thinks he's judging Jesus. In fact, Pilate stands under God's authority too. So does every president, every Congress, every governor, and every court.
What this means for American politics right now
- Watch where your hope rises and falls. On November 3, Democrats won control of both the House and the Senate. Southern Baptist Convention president Willy Rice said many conservative evangelicals were "disappointed, even devastated." Others on the left described the results as a repudiation of evangelical politics. Grief and joy are both human and fine. But when an election result feels like the gospel was won or lost, government has moved from servant to being God.
- The temptation changes parties; it doesn't disappear. This cycle, pastor-candidates such as James Talarico in Texas and Adam Hamilton in Kansas ran openly on a Christian message of loving your neighbor. For years, many progressive Christians have rightly warned against fusing faith with the Republican Party. The same warning now applies in the other direction. A Jesus who votes Democrat is just as domesticated as a Jesus who votes Republican. If we read only Romans 13 once our side holds power, we will baptize it, as others did before us.
- Name the fusion of flag and cross honestly. PRRI's 2026 survey found that about 3 in 10 Americans qualify as Christian nationalism adherents or sympathizers, including 56% of Republicans, 25% of independents and 17% of Democrats (PRRI). Pew found that 10% of Americans view Christian nationalism favorably and 31% unfavorably (Pew). Whatever we think of the label, Revelation 13 warns about any arrangement where loyalty to the nation and loyalty to God become one loyalty. Philippians 3:20 reminds us which citizenship comes first.
- Hold every administration to Romans 13's job description. Paul says government exists to restrain evil and do good, and that standard cuts across party lines. Christians on the right will press the new Congress on the unborn, religious liberty and LGBTQ+. Christians on the left will press the administration on immigrants, the poor and the abuse of power. Both are asking government to do its God-given job. The point isn't to pick one list. It's to let the whole of Scripture, not party platforms, set the questions we ask of those in power.
- Speak up when power oversteps, whoever holds it. "We must obey God rather than men" (Acts 5:29) is not a slogan for when the other party is in charge. The prophetic voice loses its credibility when it falls silent the moment our side wins.
What this means for the American church
Stop making party loyalty a test of faithfulness. In many congregations, the quickest way to have your faith questioned is to vote differently from the people in the next pew. But no ballot is a confession of faith. The church confesses "Jesus is Lord," a claim no party platform can contain. When we treat political conclusions as tests of orthodoxy, we have quietly let Caesar write our membership requirements.
Let discipleship shape politics, not the reverse. The real question is which direction the influence runs. Are we reading the news through the Gospels, or the Gospels through the news? A simple check is to ask when Scripture last changed your mind on a political question. If the answer is never, the lens may be pointing the wrong way.
Distinguish civil freedom from gospel freedom. The freedom to speak, gather and worship is a real gift. We should protect it, be grateful for it, and seek it for our neighbors as well as ourselves. But it is not the freedom of the gospel. "If the Son sets you free, you will be free indeed" (John 8:36). Paul had that freedom in chains. Believers under hostile governments have it today. No election gave it to you, and no election can take it away.
Be the kind of community the world can't produce. A local church where people who voted differently still share the table, pray together and serve the same neighbors is itself a witness. It shows a kingdom that "doesn't come from this world" and doesn't advance by winning. In a polarized season, that may be the most countercultural thing a congregation can do.
Pray for leaders by name, especially the ones you didn't vote for. Paul urges prayers "for kings and all who are in high positions" (1 Timothy 2:1-2). With power now divided in Washington, every Christian has someone in office they would rather not pray for. That is exactly where the practice works on us.
Fear God. Honor the emperor.
Peter puts it in four short phrases: "Honor everyone. Love the brotherhood. Fear God. Honor the emperor" (1 Peter 2:17). Fear goes to God. Honor goes to the emperor. Never mix them up.
So pay the tax. Pray for those in authority. Seek the good of the city. Speak up when power oversteps. But keep your worship, your ultimate loyalty and your hope of salvation for the One whose image you bear. Government under God, never in God's place.
Questions for reflection
- How did you feel on election night, and what does that reveal about where your hope rests?
- Do you reach for Romans 13 or Revelation 13 depending on who is in power?
- When did Scripture last change your mind on a political question?
- Who in office will you commit to pray for by name this week?
Recent
Under God, Never in God's Place
November 22nd, 2026
The Treasury of the Heart
November 15th, 2026
Peace in an Anxious Season: Lessons from Rebecca Pratt Interview
November 8th, 2026
Rest or escape? The Difference Matters More Than We Think
November 1st, 2026
Who's in the Boat? Trusting God in the Storm Instead of the Ballot
October 25th, 2026
Archive
2026
March
April
May
June
July
August
September
October
2025
February
March

No Comments